Jerry Best
Forward · Providence F.C.
- born
- 1901
- apps
- 454
- goals
- 217
- caps
- –
Billy Hibbert
Forward · Leeds City F.C.
- born
- 1884
- apps
- 447
- goals
- 200
- caps
- 1

Jimmy Gallagher
Midfielder · New York Field Club
- born
- 1901
- apps
- 351
- goals
- 59
- caps
- –
Bill McPherson
Central midfielder · Pawtucket Rangers
- born
- 1897
- apps
- 348
- goals
- 53
- caps
- –
Alec Lorimer
Forward · New Bedford Whalers
- born
- 1896
- apps
- 312
- goals
- 50
- caps
- –
Tom Florie
Forward · Pawtucket F.C.
- born
- 1897
- apps
- 304
- goals
- 113
- caps
- –
Johnny Harvey
Forward · Pawtucket Rangers
- age
- –
- apps
- 302
- goals
- 56
- caps
- –

Andy Auld
Central midfielder · Newark Portuguese
- born
- 1900
- apps
- 292
- goals
- 36
- caps
- –
Malcolm Goldie
Forward · New Bedford Whalers
- born
- 1893
- apps
- 278
- goals
- 63
- caps
- –

Ned Tate
Defender · Pawtucket Rangers
- born
- 1901
- apps
- 272
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Jimmy McConnell
Forward · Auchinleck Talbot F.C.
- born
- 1899
- apps
- 264
- goals
- 187
- caps
- –
Billy Adam
Forward · Pawtucket Rangers
- age
- –
- apps
- 254
- goals
- 62
- caps
- –
Jock Allan
Full-back · Dunfermline Athletic F.C.
- born
- 1891
- apps
- 254
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –
John Nelson
Forward · New York Giants
- born
- 1905
- apps
- 250
- goals
- 223
- caps
- –
Mike McLeavy
Inside forward · Bo'ness F.C.
- born
- 1898
- apps
- 249
- goals
- 107
- caps
- –
Bob Perry
Centre-back · New Bedford Whalers
- born
- 1893
- apps
- 247
- goals
- 30
- caps
- –
Tommy Fleming
Central midfielder · Fore River
- born
- 1890
- apps
- 234
- goals
- 94
- caps
- –
Bobby Curtis
Inside forward · Queen of the South F.C.
- age
- –
- apps
- 223
- goals
- 64
- caps
- –
Fred Morley
Forward · Pawtucket Rangers
- born
- 1890
- apps
- 218
- goals
- 46
- caps
- –
Nib Hogg
Forward · Pawtucket Rangers
- born
- 1903
- apps
- 189
- goals
- 40
- caps
- –
Bobby Blair
Forward · Helensburgh F.C.
- age
- –
- apps
- 187
- goals
- 127
- caps
- –
Gordon Burness
Central midfielder · Brechin City F.C.
- born
- 1906
- apps
- 182
- goals
- 26
- caps
- –
Frank McKenna
Forward · Vale of Leven F.C.
- age
- –
- apps
- 180
- goals
- 61
- caps
- –
Tucker Croft
Inside forward · Drumcondra F.C.
- age
- –
- apps
- 177
- goals
- 61
- caps
- 3
Robert Millar
Forward · New York Giants
- born
- 1889
- apps
- 173
- goals
- 60
- caps
- –
Tosher Burns
Defender · Ards F.C.
- born
- 1902
- apps
- 167
- goals
- 55
- caps
- 1
Denis Doyle
Central midfielder · New York Yankees
- born
- 1900
- apps
- 162
- goals
- 1
- caps
- 1
Bobby Walker
Inside forward · Pawtucket Rangers
- born
- 1906
- apps
- 152
- goals
- 33
- caps
- –

Bert Patenaude
Forward · Philadelphia Nationals
- born
- 1909
- apps
- 148
- goals
- 156
- caps
- –
Peter Sweeney
Forward · Beith F.C.
- age
- –
- apps
- 145
- goals
- 33
- caps
- –
Johnny Reid
Forward · Fall River F.C.
- born
- 1896
- apps
- 133
- goals
- 46
- caps
- –
Sam Kennedy
Forward · Clyde F.C.
- born
- 1899
- apps
- 129
- goals
- 40
- caps
- –
Bobby Drummond
Inside forward · Arbroath F.C.
- age
- –
- apps
- 128
- goals
- 41
- caps
- –
Willie Crilley
Forward · Brooklyn Hispano
- born
- 1901
- apps
- 125
- goals
- 64
- caps
- –
Percy Barlow
Forward · New Bedford Whalers
- born
- 1905
- apps
- 117
- goals
- 35
- caps
- –
Jock Ferguson
Defender · Arbroath F.C.
- born
- 1887
- apps
- 109
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Jimmy McAuley
Forward · Ards F.C.
- born
- 1901
- apps
- 107
- goals
- 24
- caps
- –
Arnie Oliver
Forward · Providence F.C.
- born
- 1907
- apps
- 105
- goals
- 60
- caps
- –
Walter Aspden
Inside forward · Boston Bears
- born
- 1907
- apps
- 94
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –
Walter Dick
Forward · Pawtucket Rangers
- born
- 1905
- apps
- 92
- goals
- 11
- caps
- –
Pete Fitzpatrick
Forward · Pawtucket Rangers
- age
- –
- apps
- 91
- goals
- 20
- caps
- –
Tommy McFarlane
Midfielder · Bethlehem Steel F.C.
- age
- –
- apps
- 72
- goals
- 5
- caps
- –
جان ہیمنگسلی
Forward · Pawtucket Rangers
- age
- –
- apps
- 69
- goals
- 32
- caps
- –
Bob McIntyre
Forward · Pawtucket Rangers
- born
- 1904
- apps
- 65
- goals
- 61
- caps
- –
Findlay Kerr
Goalkeeper · Bethlehem Steel F.C.
- born
- 1897
- apps
- 37
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Jack Kershaw
Forward · Shawsheen Indians
- age
- –
- apps
- 29
- goals
- 6
- caps
- –
Albert Mitchell
Forward · Tebo Yacht Basin F.C.
- age
- –
- apps
- 22
- goals
- 10
- caps
- –
Henry Margenson
Defender · United States men's national soccer team
- age
- –
- apps
- 6
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –