
Herbert Carlsson
Inside forward · New York Giants
- born
- 1896
- apps
- 448
- goals
- 133
- caps
- 20
Bart McGhee
Forward · Indiana Flooring
- born
- 1899
- apps
- 412
- goals
- 155
- caps
- –
Harry Chatton
Midfielder · Cork F.C.
- born
- 1899
- apps
- 399
- goals
- 9
- caps
- 6

Jim Brown
Central midfielder · Clyde F.C.
- born
- 1908
- apps
- 375
- goals
- 269
- caps
- –
Alec Donald
Full-back · Dunfermline Athletic F.C.
- born
- 1900
- apps
- 353
- goals
- 5
- caps
- –

Jimmy Gallagher
Midfielder · New York Field Club
- born
- 1901
- apps
- 351
- goals
- 59
- caps
- –
Geordie Henderson
Forward · Forfar Athletic F.C.
- born
- 1897
- apps
- 286
- goals
- 163
- caps
- –
John Nelson
Forward · New York Giants
- born
- 1905
- apps
- 250
- goals
- 223
- caps
- –
Hookey Leonard
Forward · Greenock Morton F.C.
- born
- 1906
- apps
- 227
- goals
- 132
- caps
- –
Bobby Curtis
Inside forward · Queen of the South F.C.
- age
- –
- apps
- 223
- goals
- 64
- caps
- –

Jimmy Douglas
Goalkeeper · New York Americans
- born
- 1898
- apps
- 204
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Frank McKenna
Forward · Vale of Leven F.C.
- age
- –
- apps
- 180
- goals
- 61
- caps
- –
Tucker Croft
Inside forward · Drumcondra F.C.
- age
- –
- apps
- 177
- goals
- 61
- caps
- 3
Robert Millar
Forward · New York Giants
- born
- 1889
- apps
- 173
- goals
- 60
- caps
- –
Peter Renzulli
Goalkeeper · New York Giants
- born
- 1895
- apps
- 172
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –
John Slavin
Midfielder · Brookhattan
- age
- –
- apps
- 171
- goals
- 8
- caps
- –
Tommy Duggan
Forward · Newark Portuguese
- born
- 1897
- apps
- 156
- goals
- 51
- caps
- –
Bobby Walker
Inside forward · Pawtucket Rangers
- born
- 1906
- apps
- 152
- goals
- 33
- caps
- –
Billy Wilson
Defender · New Bedford Whalers
- age
- –
- apps
- 138
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Willie Crilley
Forward · Brooklyn Hispano
- born
- 1901
- apps
- 125
- goals
- 64
- caps
- –
Siegfried Wortmann
Forward · First Vienna FC
- born
- 1908
- apps
- 123
- goals
- 41
- caps
- 1
David Archibald
Full-back · Shelbourne F.C.
- born
- 1902
- apps
- 122
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –
Shamus O'Brien
Forward · Kearny Celtic
- born
- 1907
- apps
- 98
- goals
- 29
- caps
- –
John Thomson
Goalkeeper · Aberdare Town F.C.
- born
- 1896
- apps
- 97
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –

Tewfik Abdullah
Forward · Egypt men's
- born
- 1896
- apps
- 91
- goals
- 27
- caps
- –
Erik Levin
Defender · Sweden men's
- born
- 1899
- apps
- 77
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Frank Tollan
Forward · New York Giants
- born
- 1901
- apps
- 69
- goals
- 8
- caps
- –
Mick Connaboy
Inside forward · Darlington F.C.
- born
- 1901
- apps
- 54
- goals
- 8
- caps
- –
Freddie Wall
Forward · Newark Portuguese
- age
- –
- apps
- 51
- goals
- 30
- caps
- –

John Duffy
Defender · New York Soccer Club
- born
- 1905
- apps
- 31
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –

Harry Farrell
Forward · Philadelphia Field Club
- born
- 1902
- apps
- 25
- goals
- 9
- caps
- –

William Findlay
Forward · Third Lanark A.C.
- born
- 1904
- apps
- 15
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –
Andrew Haddow
Forward · Ballymena United F.C.
- born
- 1903
- apps
- 1
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –

Andy Stevens
Forward · Bridgeport Hungaria
- born
- 1901
- apps
- –
- goals
- –
- caps
- –