6Gerardo Torrado
Midfielder · Indy Eleven
- born
- 1979
- apps
- 687
- goals
- 22
- caps
- 151

Éamon Zayed
Forward · Chattanooga Red Wolves SC
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 435
- goals
- 210
- caps
- 12
18Jon Busch
Goalkeeper · Indy Eleven
- born
- 1976
- apps
- 419
- goals
- 0
- caps
- 4

Jermaine Johnson
Central midfielder · Jamaica men's
- born
- 1980
- apps
- 363
- goals
- 45
- caps
- –
25Kim Do-heon
Midfielder · Seongnam FC
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 355
- goals
- 49
- caps
- 105
José Kléberson
Midfielder · Fort Lauderdale Strikers
- born
- 1979
- apps
- 334
- goals
- 41
- caps
- 32
Erick Norales
Defender · Rayo OKC
- age
- 41
- apps
- 326
- goals
- 27
- caps
- 29
5Lovel Palmer
Defender · Indy Eleven
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 302
- goals
- 47
- caps
- –
Gorka Larrea
Defensive midfielder · Indy Eleven
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 282
- goals
- 21
- caps
- 15
Colin Falvey
Defender · Indy Eleven
- age
- 41
- apps
- 279
- goals
- 24
- caps
- –
7activeAyoze García
Central midfielder · New York Cosmos
- age
- 41
- apps
- 267
- goals
- 31
- caps
- –
Souleymane Youla
Forward · K.S.K. Ronse
- born
- 1981
- apps
- 257
- goals
- 89
- caps
- –

Stephen deRoux
Midfielder · Milwaukee Wave
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 229
- goals
- 18
- caps
- –
8activeMatt Watson
Midfielder · North Carolina FC
- age
- 41
- apps
- 224
- goals
- 19
- caps
- –
19Dane Richards
Forward · Miami FC
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 223
- goals
- 34
- caps
- –
Jhulliam Bonfim
Midfielder · Uberlândia E.C.
- born
- 1988
- apps
- 220
- goals
- 80
- caps
- –
Dragan Stojkov
Midfielder · North Macedonia
- age
- 38
- apps
- 212
- goals
- 7
- caps
- 19

Kristian Nicht
Goalkeeper · Minnesota United FC
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 201
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Nicki Paterson
Midfielder · Indy Eleven
- age
- 41
- apps
- 201
- goals
- 50
- caps
- –
15Mike Ambersley
Forward · Saint Louis FC
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 194
- goals
- 48
- caps
- 4
Jair Reynoso
Forward · Indy Eleven
- age
- 41
- apps
- 185
- goals
- 91
- caps
- –
activeJustin Braun
Forward · Indy Eleven
- age
- 39
- apps
- 174
- goals
- 38
- caps
- –

Siniša Ubiparipović
Midfielder · Indy Eleven
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 174
- goals
- 23
- caps
- –

Nemanja Vuković
Defender · Indy Eleven
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 169
- goals
- 13
- caps
- –
23activeBlake Smith
Midfielder · San Antonio FC
- age
- 35
- apps
- 164
- goals
- 8
- caps
- –
Walter Ramírez
Forward · Tampa Bay Rowdies
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 164
- goals
- 10
- caps
- –
1activeEvan Newton
Goalkeeper · Indy Eleven
- age
- 38
- apps
- 163
- goals
- 0
- caps
- 5

Greg Janicki
Defender · Indy Eleven
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 148
- goals
- 9
- caps
- –
Dino Williams
Forward · Jamaica men's
- age
- 36
- apps
- 147
- goals
- 53
- caps
- –
19activeKenney Walker
Midfielder · Indy Eleven
- age
- 38
- apps
- 136
- goals
- 8
- caps
- –
92activeSoony Saad
Forward · Al Ansar FC
- age
- 34
- apps
- 134
- goals
- 24
- caps
- 17
Pedro Ferreira-Mendes
Forward · Puerto Rico FC
- age
- 36
- apps
- 131
- goals
- 35
- caps
- –
9activeRomario Williams
Forward · Miami FC
- age
- 32
- apps
- 128
- goals
- 48
- caps
- 13
Marco Franco
Defender · Miami FC
- age
- 35
- apps
- 127
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
18activeElliot Collier
Forward · Chicago Fire FC
- age
- 31
- apps
- 124
- goals
- 43
- caps
- –
30activeAndrew Carleton
Midfielder · Jicaral Sercoba
- age
- 26
- apps
- 112
- goals
- 38
- caps
- 47
Fejiro Okiomah
Defender · San Antonio FC
- age
- 36
- apps
- 103
- goals
- 5
- caps
- –
29activePaddy Barrett
Defender · Indy Eleven
- age
- 33
- apps
- 99
- goals
- 8
- caps
- –
Christian Novoa
Forward · Carabobo F.C.
- age
- 35
- apps
- 83
- goals
- 11
- caps
- –
Ben Speas
Forward · Indy Eleven
- age
- 35
- apps
- 81
- goals
- 7
- caps
- 10
Marvin Ceballos
Forward · North Carolina FC
- age
- 34
- apps
- 81
- goals
- 10
- caps
- –
4activeTyler Gibson
Midfielder · Indy Eleven
- age
- 35
- apps
- 75
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –
Charlie Rugg
Forward · SV Eintracht Trier 05
- age
- 36
- apps
- 68
- goals
- 16
- caps
- –
Carl Haworth
Forward · Ottawa Fury FC
- age
- 37
- apps
- 66
- goals
- 37
- caps
- –
Neil Shaffer
Midfielder · Harrisburg City Islanders
- age
- 37
- apps
- 64
- goals
- 7
- caps
- –
21activeAlex Crognale
Defender · Birmingham Legion FC
- age
- 32
- apps
- 63
- goals
- 5
- caps
- –
Victor Pineda
Midfielder · Fort Lauderdale Strikers
- age
- 33
- apps
- 63
- goals
- 10
- caps
- 12
Cory Miller
Defender · Indy Eleven
- age
- 38
- apps
- 61
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –