John McGinlay
Forward · Cincinnati Kings
- born
- 1964
- apps
- 623
- goals
- 350
- caps
- 13
Gino DiFlorio
Midfielder · Baltimore Blast
- born
- 1964
- apps
- 468
- goals
- 444
- caps
- 1
Troy Dusosky
Defender · Milwaukee Wave United
- born
- 1976
- apps
- 468
- goals
- 163
- caps
- –

Greg Sutton
Goalkeeper · CF Montréal
- born
- 1977
- apps
- 351
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Lazo Alavanja
Midfielder · Indiana Hoosiers men's soccer
- born
- 1977
- apps
- 271
- goals
- 42
- caps
- –
Matt Caution
Forward · Orlando Sharks
- born
- 1974
- apps
- 268
- goals
- 43
- caps
- –
Philippe Godoy
Midfielder · Atlanta Silverbacks
- born
- 1971
- apps
- 252
- goals
- 29
- caps
- –
Allen Eller
Forward · Akron Zips men's soccer
- born
- 1976
- apps
- 227
- goals
- 153
- caps
- –
Nelson Akwari
Defender · Orange County SC
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 218
- goals
- 1
- caps
- 10
Fred DeGand
Defender · Bowling Green Falcons men's soccer
- born
- 1979
- apps
- 188
- goals
- 28
- caps
- –
Mike Apple
Forward · Akron Zips men's soccer
- born
- 1977
- apps
- 184
- goals
- 61
- caps
- –

Eric Descombes
Defender · Mauritania men's
- born
- 1971
- apps
- 171
- goals
- 16
- caps
- 2

Connally Edozien
Forward · Fort Lauderdale Strikers
- born
- 1978
- apps
- 117
- goals
- 18
- caps
- –
Ryan Lucas
Forward · Galway United F.C.
- born
- 1977
- apps
- 116
- goals
- 29
- caps
- 24
Steve Armas
Midfielder · Salem City FC
- born
- 1977
- apps
- 100
- goals
- 10
- caps
- –
Luis Labastida
Forward · California Gold
- born
- 1975
- apps
- 98
- goals
- 44
- caps
- –
Jim Adams
Goalkeeper · Cincinnati Excite
- born
- 1969
- apps
- 85
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –
Daniel Alvarez
Midfielder · Furman Paladins men's soccer
- born
- 1978
- apps
- 82
- goals
- 5
- caps
- –
Dominic Schell
Forward · Vitesse Dallas
- born
- 1977
- apps
- 78
- goals
- 14
- caps
- –
Jason Cairns
Forward · New Jersey Stallions
- age
- –
- apps
- 77
- goals
- 21
- caps
- –
Juan Sastoque
Forward · Cal State Northridge Matadors men's soccer
- born
- 1977
- apps
- 72
- goals
- 16
- caps
- –
Bobby Meyer
Defender · Cincinnati Riverhawks
- age
- –
- apps
- 62
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –
Christof Lindenmayer
Forward · Loyola Greyhounds men's soccer
- born
- 1977
- apps
- 52
- goals
- 7
- caps
- –
Leslie Fitzpatrick
Midfielder · Rochester Rhinos
- born
- 1978
- apps
- 45
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –
Peter Byaruhanga
Forward · UAB Blazers men's soccer
- born
- 1979
- apps
- 37
- goals
- 8
- caps
- –
Craig Yacks
Forward · Yale Bulldogs men's soccer
- born
- 1976
- apps
- 34
- goals
- 7
- caps
- –
J. T. Roberts
Midfielder · Cincinnati Riverhawks
- born
- 1975
- apps
- 22
- goals
- 5
- caps
- –
Matt Reiswerg
Goalkeeper · Indiana Hoosiers men's soccer
- born
- 1980
- apps
- 8
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
جیریمی ہارکنز
Midfielder · Windsor Stars
- age
- –
- apps
- 4
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –
Chris Pfau
Forward · Cincinnati Riverhawks
- born
- 1967
- apps
- –
- goals
- –
- caps
- –
Jay Mims
Position unrecorded · Cincinnati Riverhawks
- age
- 39
- apps
- –
- goals
- –
- caps
- –
جو مرک
Position unrecorded · Buffalo Bulls men's soccer
- born
- 1975
- apps
- –
- goals
- –
- caps
- –