7Nat Borchers
Defender · Portland Timbers
- born
- 1981
- apps
- 343
- goals
- 13
- caps
- –
Ryan Johnson
Forward · Rayo OKC
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 305
- goals
- 65
- caps
- 36

Todd Dunivant
Defender · Stanford Cardinal men's soccer
- born
- 1980
- apps
- 286
- goals
- 7
- caps
- –

Josh Simpson
Midfielder · BSC Young Boys
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 277
- goals
- 46
- caps
- 25
21Clarence Goodson
Defender · San Jose Earthquakes
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 261
- goals
- 25
- caps
- –
activeRobbie Findley
Forward · Oregon State Beavers men's soccer
- age
- 41
- apps
- 256
- goals
- 62
- caps
- –
26Collen Warner
Midfielder · FC Helsingør
- born
- 1988
- apps
- 239
- goals
- 9
- caps
- –
20Mehdi Ballouchy
Midfielder · Creighton Bluejays men's soccer
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 224
- goals
- 18
- caps
- 6
Ryan Guy
Central midfielder · San Diego Toreros men's soccer
- age
- 41
- apps
- 209
- goals
- 34
- caps
- 33

Aaron Pitchkolan
Defender · Minnesota United FC
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 171
- goals
- 15
- caps
- –

Aaron King
Forward · Colorado Springs Switchbacks FC
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 168
- goals
- 53
- caps
- –

Caleb Norkus
Defender · Bayamón FC
- born
- 1979
- apps
- 163
- goals
- 16
- caps
- 2

Abe Thompson
Forward · Fort Lauderdale Strikers
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 161
- goals
- 34
- caps
- 6
1activeTally Hall
Goalkeeper · D.C. United
- age
- 41
- apps
- 161
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
David Bulow
Midfielder · Bowdoin Polar Bears men's soccer
- born
- 1980
- apps
- 158
- goals
- 61
- caps
- –

Colin Clark
Central midfielder · SMU Mustangs men's soccer
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 151
- goals
- 20
- caps
- –
Brian Shriver
Forward · North Carolina FC
- age
- 39
- apps
- 149
- goals
- 38
- caps
- –
2activeTyler Ruthven
Defender · Jacksonville Armada FC
- age
- 38
- apps
- 130
- goals
- 4
- caps
- –
Brayton Knapp
Defender · Rochester Rhinos
- born
- 1986
- apps
- 119
- goals
- 13
- caps
- –
activeJeb Brovsky
Defender · Minnesota United FC
- age
- 38
- apps
- 117
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –
Raphael Cox
Midfielder · Charlotte Independence
- born
- 1986
- apps
- 117
- goals
- 9
- caps
- –
Brad Stisser
Midfielder · Loyola Marymount Lions men's soccer
- age
- 40
- apps
- 115
- goals
- 16
- caps
- –
Chad Burt
Midfielder · FC Edmonton
- born
- 1988
- apps
- 115
- goals
- 124
- caps
- –

John Cunliffe
Forward · Blackburn Rovers F.C.
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 113
- goals
- 37
- caps
- –

Tim Merritt
Defender · CASL Elite
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 98
- goals
- 9
- caps
- –
John Pulido
Midfielder · FIU Panthers men's soccer
- born
- 1981
- apps
- 92
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –

Devon McTavish
Midfielder · D.C. United
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 90
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –

Jarrod Smith
Forward · New Zealand
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 86
- goals
- 28
- caps
- 12

Mike Zaher
Defender · Rochester Rhinos
- born
- 1985
- apps
- 85
- goals
- 6
- caps
- –

Kyle Brown
Forward · Austin Aztex
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 77
- goals
- 19
- caps
- –
31Luis Robles
Goalkeeper · Red Bull New York
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 77
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
activeSola Abolaji
Defender · Thunder Bay Chill
- age
- 41
- apps
- 75
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Brett Branan
Defender · Clemson Tigers men's soccer
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 65
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –
activeMasaki Hemmi
Midfielder · Real Colorado SC
- age
- 40
- apps
- 65
- goals
- 6
- caps
- –
Mike Seth
Forward · Colorado Springs Switchbacks FC
- age
- 39
- apps
- 65
- goals
- 5
- caps
- –
David Wagenfuhr
Defender · Creighton Bluejays men's soccer
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 64
- goals
- 3
- caps
- –
Miguel Guante
Defender · Portland Timbers U23s
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 63
- goals
- 5
- caps
- –
Lance Parker
Goalkeeper · FC Edmonton
- born
- 1985
- apps
- 60
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Austin Washington
Defender · Gonzaga Bulldogs men's soccer
- age
- 41
- apps
- 53
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
activePeter Lowry
Midfielder · Santa Clara Broncos men's soccer
- age
- 41
- apps
- 43
- goals
- 6
- caps
- –

James Thorpe
Goalkeeper · Western Mass Pioneers
- born
- 1985
- apps
- 33
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Nate Northup
Defender · Wilmington Hammerheads FC
- born
- 1981
- apps
- 32
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –
Brandon Moss
Midfielder · Chicago Fire U-23
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 23
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
24activeZach Prince
Midfielder · Charleston Battery
- age
- 38
- apps
- 22
- goals
- 5
- caps
- –
Lance Friesz
Goalkeeper · San Diego Toreros men's soccer
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 21
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Alejandro Salazar
Midfielder · Sydney FC
- born
- 1984
- apps
- 20
- goals
- 15
- caps
- –
Tyrel Lacey
Goalkeeper · Lyn 1896 FK
- born
- 1986
- apps
- 14
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Martin Hutton
Goalkeeper · Clemson Tigers men's soccer
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 7
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –