Frank Worthington
Forward · Hinckley United F.C.
- born
- 1948
- apps
- 836
- goals
- 262
- caps
- 8
Kevin Keelan
Goalkeeper · Tampa Bay Rowdies
- born
- 1941
- apps
- 761
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Billy Ronson
Midfielder · Baltimore Blast
- born
- 1957
- apps
- 743
- goals
- 176
- caps
- –
Peter Ward
Forward · Tampa Bay Terror
- born
- 1955
- apps
- 721
- goals
- 390
- caps
- 3

Wim Suurbier
Full-back · AS Monaco FC
- born
- 1945
- apps
- 678
- goals
- 25
- caps
- 60
Paul Dougherty
Forward · Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC
- born
- 1966
- apps
- 647
- goals
- 497
- caps
- –
Tatu
Forward · Wichita Wings
- born
- 1962
- apps
- 617
- goals
- 760
- caps
- –

Jan van der Veen
Midfielder · Helmond Sport
- born
- 1948
- apps
- 599
- goals
- 65
- caps
- –
Ken Fogarty
Defender · Tampa Bay Rowdies
- born
- 1955
- apps
- 580
- goals
- 30
- caps
- –
Wes McLeod
Defender · Dallas Sidekicks
- born
- 1957
- apps
- 553
- goals
- 120
- caps
- –
Stuart Lee
Forward · Dallas Sidekicks
- born
- 1953
- apps
- 551
- goals
- 232
- caps
- –
Lee Tschantret
Defender · Philadelphia KiXX
- born
- 1969
- apps
- 549
- goals
- 415
- caps
- –

Tommy Smith
Defender · England
- born
- 1945
- apps
- 533
- goals
- 38
- caps
- 1

Keith Peacock
Midfielder · Tampa Bay Rowdies
- born
- 1945
- apps
- 532
- goals
- 92
- caps
- –

Peter Nogly
Defender · VfB Lübeck
- born
- 1947
- apps
- 530
- goals
- 88
- caps
- 4
Kevin Sloan
Forward · United States national futsal team
- born
- 1965
- apps
- 527
- goals
- 522
- caps
- –

Mark Lawrenson
Defender · Chesham United F.C.
- born
- 1957
- apps
- 527
- goals
- 26
- caps
- 39

Rodney Marsh
Forward · Tampa Bay Rowdies
- born
- 1944
- apps
- 517
- goals
- 223
- caps
- 12

Ian Anderson
Defender · Canton Invaders
- born
- 1954
- apps
- 514
- goals
- 198
- caps
- –
Flemming Lund
Midfielder · Wichita Wings
- born
- 1952
- apps
- 507
- goals
- 48
- caps
- 33

Clyde Best
Forward · Los Angeles Lazers
- born
- 1951
- apps
- 494
- goals
- 165
- caps
- 2
Ralph Black
Defender · Portland Pythons
- born
- 1963
- apps
- 492
- goals
- 126
- caps
- –
Manuel Rojas
Midfielder · Chicago Power
- born
- 1954
- apps
- 482
- goals
- 148
- caps
- –
Terry Rowe
Midfielder · Wichita Wings
- born
- 1964
- apps
- 481
- goals
- 94
- caps
- –

Sam Allardyce
Centre-back · Preston North End F.C.
- born
- 1954
- apps
- 479
- goals
- 32
- caps
- –
David Moss
Midfielder · Trowbridge Town F.C.
- born
- 1952
- apps
- 478
- goals
- 157
- caps
- –

Ricky Hill
Midfielder · Chertsey Town F.C.
- born
- 1959
- apps
- 475
- goals
- 56
- caps
- 3
Franz Gerber
Forward · FC St. Pauli
- born
- 1953
- apps
- 471
- goals
- 254
- caps
- –
Graham Paddon
Forward · Alfreton Town F.C.
- born
- 1950
- apps
- 470
- goals
- 44
- caps
- 1
Steve Kinsey
Forward · Chesterfield F.C.
- born
- 1963
- apps
- 468
- goals
- 203
- caps
- –
Mick McGuire
Midfielder · Grantham Town F.C.
- born
- 1952
- apps
- 457
- goals
- 26
- caps
- –
Tony Towers
Midfielder · Rochdale A.F.C.
- born
- 1952
- apps
- 450
- goals
- 46
- caps
- 3
Tommy Langley
Forward · Wokingham & Emmbrook F.C.
- born
- 1958
- apps
- 448
- goals
- 109
- caps
- 1
John Gorman
Defender · Gillingham F.C.
- born
- 1949
- apps
- 447
- goals
- 15
- caps
- –

Tony Morley
Central midfielder · Ħamrun Spartans F.C.
- born
- 1954
- apps
- 444
- goals
- 77
- caps
- 6
Eddie Firmani
Forward · Tampa Bay Rowdies
- born
- 1933
- apps
- 443
- goals
- 240
- caps
- 3
Stewart Jump
Defender · Tacoma Stars
- born
- 1952
- apps
- 443
- goals
- 41
- caps
- –
Stewart Scullion
Central midfielder · Portland Timbers
- born
- 1946
- apps
- 443
- goals
- 89
- caps
- –
Perry Van der Beck
Midfielder · Tampa Bay Terror
- born
- 1959
- apps
- 437
- goals
- 75
- caps
- –
Lenny Glover
Midfielder · Harlow Town F.C.
- born
- 1944
- apps
- 429
- goals
- 58
- caps
- –
David Byrne
Forward · Santos F.C.
- born
- 1960
- apps
- 427
- goals
- 226
- caps
- –
Joey Fink
Forward · NYU Violets men's soccer
- born
- 1951
- apps
- 421
- goals
- 300
- caps
- –
Don McAllister
Defender · Vitória F.C.
- born
- 1953
- apps
- 409
- goals
- 17
- caps
- –
Peter Barnes
Central midfielder · Cliftonville F.C.
- born
- 1957
- apps
- 408
- goals
- 57
- caps
- 31
Peter Anderson
Midfielder · Hendon F.C.
- born
- 1949
- apps
- 407
- goals
- 108
- caps
- –
Nicky Johns
Goalkeeper · Maidstone United F.C.
- born
- 1957
- apps
- 398
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Roy Wegerle
Forward · South Florida Bulls men's soccer
- born
- 1964
- apps
- 389
- goals
- 120
- caps
- –
David Vaudreuil
Midfielder · Princeton Tigers men's soccer
- born
- 1966
- apps
- 387
- goals
- 102
- caps
- –