
Lee Hughes
Forward · Stourport Swifts F.C.
- born
- 1976
- apps
- 765
- goals
- 335
- caps
- –
Julian Alsop
Forward · Monmouth Town F.C.
- born
- 1973
- apps
- 718
- goals
- 307
- caps
- –
Darren Collins
Forward · Petersfield Town F.C.
- born
- 1967
- apps
- 685
- goals
- 387
- caps
- –
11George Best
Central midfielder · Tobermore United F.C.
- born
- 1946
- apps
- 661
- goals
- 235
- caps
- 37
Andy Thackeray
Defender · Manchester City F.C.
- born
- 1968
- apps
- 574
- goals
- 48
- caps
- –
Marlon Harewood
Forward · Nuneaton Town F.C.
- born
- 1979
- apps
- 571
- goals
- 144
- caps
- –
Chris Mackenzie
Goalkeeper · Alfreton Town F.C.
- born
- 1972
- apps
- 570
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –
Mickey Brown
Midfielder · Shawbury United F.C.
- born
- 1968
- apps
- 551
- goals
- 46
- caps
- –

Sam Ricketts
Full-back · Coventry City F.C.
- born
- 1981
- apps
- 551
- goals
- 13
- caps
- 52
Mark Taylor
Midfielder · Rugby Town F.C.
- born
- 1966
- apps
- 545
- goals
- 22
- caps
- –
Eddie McGoldrick
Defender · Corby Town F.C.
- born
- 1965
- apps
- 531
- goals
- 38
- caps
- 16
Daryl Burgess
Defender · Bromsgrove Rovers F.C.
- born
- 1971
- apps
- 525
- goals
- 12
- caps
- –
Dean Barrick
Defender · Hucknall Town F.C.
- born
- 1969
- apps
- 516
- goals
- 17
- caps
- –
Alex Sykes
Midfielder · Shortwood United F.C.
- born
- 1974
- apps
- 514
- goals
- 141
- caps
- –

Jon Sammels
Midfielder · England
- born
- 1945
- apps
- 510
- goals
- 67
- caps
- –
Malcolm Shotton
Defender · Barnsley F.C.
- born
- 1957
- apps
- 499
- goals
- 25
- caps
- –

Paul Barnes
Forward · Hinckley United F.C.
- born
- 1967
- apps
- 488
- goals
- 185
- caps
- –
Mike Gibson
Goalkeeper · Gillingham F.C.
- born
- 1939
- apps
- 487
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –

Lee Mansell
Midfielder · Bristol Rovers F.C.
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 485
- goals
- 35
- caps
- –
Trevor Morley
Forward · Sogndal Fotball
- born
- 1961
- apps
- 459
- goals
- 154
- caps
- –
Reg Ryan
Midfielder · Nuneaton Town F.C.
- born
- 1925
- apps
- 449
- goals
- 70
- caps
- 17
Terry Branston
Defender · Nuneaton Town F.C.
- born
- 1938
- apps
- 447
- goals
- 12
- caps
- –
Duane Darby
Forward · Hednesford Town F.C.
- born
- 1973
- apps
- 443
- goals
- 135
- caps
- –
Drewe Broughton
Forward · Darlington F.C.
- born
- 1978
- apps
- 433
- goals
- 76
- caps
- –
Gerry Baker
Forward · Worcester City F.C.
- born
- 1938
- apps
- 428
- goals
- 175
- caps
- –
Ian Clarkson
Defender · Alvechurch F.C.
- born
- 1970
- apps
- 422
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –

Iyseden Christie
Forward · Bedworth United F.C.
- born
- 1976
- apps
- 420
- goals
- 115
- caps
- –
Jon Gittens
Centre-back · Dorchester Town F.C.
- born
- 1964
- apps
- 419
- goals
- 21
- caps
- –
Dean Walling
Defender · Saint Kitts and Nevis men's
- born
- 1969
- apps
- 418
- goals
- 45
- caps
- –
Paul Culpin
Forward · Kirby Muxloe S.C.
- born
- 1962
- apps
- 418
- goals
- 269
- caps
- –
Kenny Mower
Full-back · Nuneaton Town F.C.
- born
- 1960
- apps
- 415
- goals
- 8
- caps
- –
activeAlex Rodman
Winger · Bristol Rovers F.C.
- age
- 39
- apps
- 406
- goals
- 65
- caps
- –
Andrew Corbett
Defender · Hereford United F.C.
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 405
- goals
- 42
- caps
- –
Tom Curtis
Midfielder · Loughborough University F.C.
- born
- 1973
- apps
- 400
- goals
- 13
- caps
- –

Paul Hendrie
Midfielder · Bath City F.C.
- born
- 1954
- apps
- 397
- goals
- 19
- caps
- –
Tony Richards
Forward · Dudley Town F.C.
- born
- 1934
- apps
- 397
- goals
- 214
- caps
- –
Frank Upton
Centre-back · Nuneaton Town F.C.
- born
- 1934
- apps
- 391
- goals
- 24
- caps
- –
Simon Travis
Defender · Brackley Town F.C.
- born
- 1977
- apps
- 391
- goals
- 11
- caps
- –
activeKyle Perry
Forward · Hednesford Town F.C.
- age
- 40
- apps
- 387
- goals
- 90
- caps
- –
Jimmy Holmes
Full-back · Nuneaton Town F.C.
- born
- 1953
- apps
- 385
- goals
- 23
- caps
- 30

Terry Angus
Defender · Nuneaton Town F.C.
- born
- 1966
- apps
- 379
- goals
- 18
- caps
- –
Steve Whitehall
Forward · Marine F.C.
- born
- 1966
- apps
- 376
- goals
- 123
- caps
- –
Daire Doyle
Midfielder · Shelbourne F.C.
- born
- 1980
- apps
- 375
- goals
- 25
- caps
- –
Jay Denny
Midfielder · Halesowen Town F.C.
- age
- 40
- apps
- 375
- goals
- 30
- caps
- –
Mike Stringfellow
Midfielder · Nuneaton Town F.C.
- born
- 1943
- apps
- 372
- goals
- 92
- caps
- –
33activeCyrus Christie
Defender · Hull City A.F.C.
- age
- 34
- apps
- 368
- goals
- 10
- caps
- –

Anthony Charles
Defender · Worcester City F.C.
- born
- 1981
- apps
- 366
- goals
- 19
- caps
- –
Frank Murphy
Midfielder · Corby Town F.C.
- born
- 1959
- apps
- 365
- goals
- 155
- caps
- –