Mitchell Downie
Goalkeeper · Altrincham F.C.
- born
- 1923
- apps
- 563
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
David Pugh
Defender · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1947
- apps
- 522
- goals
- 26
- caps
- –

Leo Fortune-West
Forward · Armthorpe Welfare F.C.
- born
- 1971
- apps
- 454
- goals
- 124
- caps
- –

Luke Beckett
Forward · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1976
- apps
- 450
- goals
- 180
- caps
- –
Andy Saville
Forward · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1964
- apps
- 449
- goals
- 122
- caps
- –
Billy Whitehurst
Forward · Frickley Athletic F.C.
- born
- 1959
- apps
- 417
- goals
- 86
- caps
- –
Tommy McDonald
Inside forward · Caledonian F.C.
- born
- 1895
- apps
- 416
- goals
- 111
- caps
- –
Terry Gray
Midfielder · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1954
- apps
- 382
- goals
- 80
- caps
- –
Clint Marcelle
Forward · Trinidad and Tobago men's
- born
- 1968
- apps
- 375
- goals
- 43
- caps
- –
Jeff Barmby
Forward · Selby Town F.C.
- born
- 1943
- apps
- 360
- goals
- 156
- caps
- –
Matt Redmile
Defender · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1976
- apps
- 360
- goals
- 19
- caps
- –
Ian McKechnie
Goalkeeper · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1941
- apps
- 355
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Chris Marples
Goalkeeper · Chesterfield F.C.
- born
- 1964
- apps
- 337
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Les Collinson
Midfielder · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1935
- apps
- 332
- goals
- 16
- caps
- –
Arnold Kendall
Central midfielder · Bridlington Town A.F.C.
- born
- 1925
- apps
- 314
- goals
- 50
- caps
- –
Dale Banton
Forward · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1961
- apps
- 311
- goals
- 100
- caps
- –
Paul Rickers
Midfielder · Guiseley A.F.C.
- born
- 1975
- apps
- 298
- goals
- 22
- caps
- –

Tyrone Thompson
Midfielder · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1982
- apps
- 278
- goals
- 11
- caps
- –
Tony Galvin
Central midfielder · Gateshead F.C.
- born
- 1956
- apps
- 277
- goals
- 22
- caps
- 29
John Bettany
Midfielder · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1937
- apps
- 273
- goals
- 32
- caps
- –
Paul Feasey
Defender · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1933
- apps
- 271
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Leigh Jenkinson
Central midfielder · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1969
- apps
- 260
- goals
- 25
- caps
- –
Ron Spence
Central midfielder · Scarborough F.C.
- born
- 1927
- apps
- 260
- goals
- 25
- caps
- –
Johnny Goodchild
Forward · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1939
- apps
- 238
- goals
- 71
- caps
- –

Peter Gilbert
Defender · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 237
- goals
- 5
- caps
- 10
Jimmy Mann
Midfielder · Goole Town F.C.
- born
- 1952
- apps
- 236
- goals
- 31
- caps
- –
Paul Showler
Central midfielder · Sheffield Wednesday F.C.
- born
- 1966
- apps
- 227
- goals
- 41
- caps
- –
Malcolm Thompson
Forward · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1946
- apps
- 222
- goals
- 74
- caps
- –
Mike Milner
Centre-back · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1939
- apps
- 213
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Terry Barwick
Midfielder · Bottesford Town F.C.
- born
- 1983
- apps
- 196
- goals
- 14
- caps
- –
George Murphy
Forward · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1915
- apps
- 195
- goals
- 52
- caps
- –
Gary Pollard
Defender · Eastwood Town F.C.
- born
- 1959
- apps
- 192
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –
activeLuke Medley
Forward · Chatham Town F.C.
- age
- 37
- apps
- 189
- goals
- 34
- caps
- –
Cliff Hubbard
Forward · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1911
- apps
- 187
- goals
- 59
- caps
- –
Jason Blunt
Midfielder · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1977
- apps
- 181
- goals
- 13
- caps
- –
Joe Turner
Goalkeeper · Denaby United F.C.
- born
- 1931
- apps
- 176
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Rory Prendergast
Midfielder · Clevedon Town F.C.
- born
- 1978
- apps
- 170
- goals
- 14
- caps
- –
Charles McDermott
Full-back · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1912
- apps
- 161
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –
Chris Tate
Forward · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1977
- apps
- 157
- goals
- 30
- caps
- –
Jason Harris
Forward · Selby Town F.C.
- born
- 1976
- apps
- 155
- goals
- 27
- caps
- –
George Handley
Midfielder · Hallam F.C.
- born
- 1886
- apps
- 153
- goals
- 37
- caps
- –

James Dudgeon
Defender · Ilkeston F.C.
- born
- 1981
- apps
- 133
- goals
- 13
- caps
- –
Tony McShane
Central midfielder · Brantwood F.C.
- born
- 1927
- apps
- 126
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –
Jimmy Loughran
Defender · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1897
- apps
- 125
- goals
- 13
- caps
- –
Joe Ford
Forward · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1886
- apps
- 107
- goals
- 12
- caps
- –
Jake Ruecroft
Defender · Goole A.F.C.
- born
- 1915
- apps
- 106
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –
Len Dunderdale
Forward · Lincoln City F.C.
- born
- 1915
- apps
- 106
- goals
- 52
- caps
- –
Mick Norbury
Forward · Ossett Albion A.F.C.
- born
- 1969
- apps
- 96
- goals
- 21
- caps
- –