
Fred Taylor
Central midfielder · Maidstone United F.C. (1987)
- born
- 1884
- apps
- 301
- goals
- 16
- caps
- –
Len Smelt
Full-back · Frickley Athletic F.C.
- born
- 1885
- apps
- 273
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –
Edmund Eyre
Central midfielder · Rotherham Town F.C.
- born
- 1882
- apps
- 184
- goals
- 35
- caps
- –

Alonzo Drake
Forward · Rotherham Town F.C.
- born
- 1884
- apps
- 161
- goals
- 34
- caps
- –
Fred Laycock
Inside forward · Hereford United F.C.
- born
- 1897
- apps
- 160
- goals
- 64
- caps
- –
John Westwood
Midfielder · Rotherham Town F.C.
- born
- 1886
- apps
- 138
- goals
- 2
- caps
- –

Joe Ryalls
Forward · Chesterfield F.C.
- born
- 1881
- apps
- 136
- goals
- 8
- caps
- –
James Harrop
Defender · Rotherham Town F.C.
- born
- 1884
- apps
- 133
- goals
- 4
- caps
- –
Philip Bratley
Midfielder · Worksop Town F.C.
- born
- 1880
- apps
- 130
- goals
- 7
- caps
- –
Walter Spratt
Full-back · Leyton Orient F.C.
- born
- 1892
- apps
- 123
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –
Laurie Burkinshaw
Central midfielder · Mexborough Athletic F.C.
- born
- 1893
- apps
- 120
- goals
- 19
- caps
- –
Jack Foster
Forward · Castleford Town F.C.
- born
- 1877
- apps
- 114
- goals
- 73
- caps
- –

Willis Rippon
Forward · Kilnhurst Colliery F.C.
- born
- 1886
- apps
- 107
- goals
- 49
- caps
- –

Charles Elliott
Forward · Rotherham Town F.C.
- born
- 1896
- apps
- 86
- goals
- 26
- caps
- –

Bert Powell
Forward · Ashfield United F.C.
- born
- 1880
- apps
- 47
- goals
- 8
- caps
- –
Alfred Brown
Central midfielder · Stalybridge Celtic F.C.
- born
- 1898
- apps
- 37
- goals
- 1
- caps
- –

Thomas Shufflebotham
Defender · Brentford F.C.
- born
- 1881
- apps
- 33
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Albert Platts
Forward · Rotherham Town F.C.
- born
- 1883
- apps
- 29
- goals
- 4
- caps
- –
Horace Fletcher
Inside forward · Mexborough Town A.F.C.
- born
- 1876
- apps
- 28
- goals
- 6
- caps
- –
Joby Godfrey
Forward · Denaby United F.C.
- born
- 1894
- apps
- 25
- goals
- 4
- caps
- –
Harold Buddery
Forward · Rotherham Town F.C.
- born
- 1889
- apps
- 22
- goals
- –
- caps
- –
Harold Hall
Defender · Grimsby Town F.C.
- born
- 1887
- apps
- 20
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Joseph Depledge
Defender · Mansfield Town F.C.
- born
- 1897
- apps
- 5
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Alf Wilson
Full-back · Rotherham Town F.C.
- born
- 1890
- apps
- 2
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
George Crowther
Inside forward · Rotherham Town F.C.
- born
- 1891
- apps
- 2
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Charles Howson
Defender · Mansfield Town F.C.
- born
- 1896
- apps
- 1
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Walter Eaton
Full-back · Rotherham County F.C.
- born
- 1881
- apps
- 1
- goals
- 0
- caps
- –
Ben Shearman
Central midfielder · Gainsborough Trinity F.C.
- born
- 1884
- apps
- –
- goals
- –
- caps
- –
Tommy Brown
Midfielder · Bradford (Park Avenue) A.F.C.
- born
- 1897
- apps
- –
- goals
- –
- caps
- –